| #2 | (2) | Baldwin-Wallace | beat | #7 | (7) | Muskingum | 35 | to | 28 |
| #8 | (8) | Capital | lost to | #1 | (1) | Mt Union | 17 | to | 65 |
| #4 | (4) | Heidelberg | beat | #9 | (9) | Otterbein | 69 | to | 13 |
| #5 | (6) | Marietta | beat | #6 | (5) | Wilmington OH | 44 | to | 14 |
| #1 | (1) | Mt Union | beat | #8 | (8) | Capital | 65 | to | 17 |
| #7 | (7) | Muskingum | lost to | #2 | (2) | Baldwin-Wallace | 28 | to | 35 |
| #3 | (3) | Ohio Northern | beat | #2 | (2) | Mt St Joseph | 49 | to | 42 |
| #9 | (9) | Otterbein | lost to | #4 | (4) | Heidelberg | 13 | to | 69 |
| #6 | (5) | Wilmington OH | lost to | #5 | (6) | Marietta | 14 | to | 44 |